im a huge metal gear fan so my biased choice would have to go to Metal Gear Solid 5 The Phantom Pain. Just kinda sucks how the game isn’t a finished product 
I thought you meant which is was the best GOTY edition if any game.
Which would be RDR GOTY for me.
That’s definitely a good game, GOTY version or not 
But my question was based on games that came out this year.
Hmm Would it still be Grand Theft Auto. Although Fallout and Battlefront are looking pretty sweet!
I doubt Battlefront would win other than die hard fans loving the Star Wars brand. Cause from what I hear, the game is not living up to a $60 price tag. EA, you devils…